Rerurn to Romy the Cat's Site


In the Forum: Musical Discussions
In the Thread: Bach, Brandenburg Concertos
Post Subject: The LIVE Brandenburgs?Posted by Romy the Cat on: 10/2/2008

Well, the DG Archiv had very few, or ever, “better moments” in term of recording quality.  With Brandenburg Concertos on LP I have the same problem as you do. I have some recordings that I more or less like on LP but I never was comfortable with sound. In fact I tend do not list the Brandenburgs on record and prefer CDs as the sound not as I would like it to be. My favorite contemporary recordings are by Boston Baroque from beginning of 90s and by Orchestra of the Age of Enlightenment from end of the 80s (both on the period instruments)

Even they do not do what I feel would be ultimate take on the Brandenburg Concertos. All records that I have are studio recording but they need to be LIVE. I never heard LIVE performance of the Concertos with me in attendance (I head just a separate movement once). It was not good play that time but I have a very clear vision how they shell be played and how they shell be sound LIVE.  I head also a live-to tape broadcast from Tanglewood on FM with  Bernstein or somebody else from 70s doing Brandenburgs – it was very bad sonically – the  Tanglewood is not the best place for this music perhaps…

If someone know any interning life recording of Brandenburg Concertos, perhaps from some kind of festival, then it might be interesting if it is not even on LP…

The Cat

Rerurn to Romy the Cat's Site