Rerurn to Romy the Cat's Site


In the Forum: Didital Things
In the Thread: K-Stereo Ambience Recovery Processor
Post Subject: “You may be hearing material that you would never hear at a live concert”Posted by Romy the Cat on: 11/21/2007
 peter foster wrote:
I mention this because your comments about Playlist 07; Song 02 and Song 03 are difficult for me to reconcile.  On my system the upright bass is heard with very fine detail and all of the complex harmonics that follow the fundamentals are clearly heard.  To me, this is a toure de force recording of upright bass made with incredibly sensitive microphones that are certainly more sensitive than many human ears.  Recently, I was making a reference recording of a new archtop guitar and testing various microphones positioned at the edge of the nearfield.  I would pluck an open string and only when I heard complete silence I would then pluck the next open string and so forth.  When I played back that recording (with gain) there was absolutely no point of silence between plucking each string because the microphones were just so sensitive.  That is exactly the kind of sensitivity I am hearing on Playlist 07; Song 02 and Song 03.  In amplifying a very fine recording, you may very well be hearing material that you would never ever hear in an audience at a live concert.  On my system and to my hearing those tracks are perfect upright bass
Well, it would not be directly related to K-Stereo but I very much disagree with the sentiment that Playlist 07; Song 02 and Song 03 is right representation of music or I would say Sound to me more correctly. It is effective and showy it does all those artificial audio tricks but it has completely no signature of event. In this recording there is just an attitude of recording engineer, sort of Audio Victory, but the sound related to the musicality itself is moved at the very back burner of attention. If you allow Peter I might post a fragment of this track here in order other understand what the conversation all about. The upper-bass is recorded as the typical hi-fi show demo track should be recoprded  - courtesy of the zillions of identical jazz recordings, the Patricia Barber and the Tree Blind Mice recordings made audiophiles feel that without upper-bass chest pressure there is no bass… I do not feel it is correct and although I do admit that it is impressive but I do also fell that this impressiveness is very superficial and based upon irrational snuck expectations, egos and substitution of values.

Rgs,
Romy the Cat

Rerurn to Romy the Cat's Site