Rerurn to Romy the Cat's Site


In the Forum: Musical Discussions
In the Thread: The bso and andris nelsons and declining interest
Post Subject: Bruckner’s FifthPosted by Romy the Cat on: 11/20/2026

Bruckner’s Fifth is a strange piece for me. I first became familiar with the Boston Philharmonic Orchestra through Bruckner’s Fifth, although I don’t remember exactly when. After moving to Boston from Philadelphia, I attended a few Boston Philharmonic concerts and wasn’t particularly impressed.

Then, sometime around 2008 or 2009, I went to hear Bruckner’s Fifth. It was a few years after Zander had recorded the symphony in London. The concert was rather boring, typical Zander stuff. He was trying to accomplish something without quite knowing what it was, while the young musicians in the orchestra seemed to be pulling in different directions, with little idea of how to bring everything together.

And then, somewhere in the second half of the final movement, the fucking stars aligned. They delivered a finale that made my hair stand on end. I had never imagined that a third- or fourth-tier orchestra, right here in Boston, performing outside Symphony Hall in what was practically an acoustic basement, could produce playing of such extraordinary quality.

The musicians’ body language was particularly revealing. They themselves could hardly believe what had just happened. It was truly, truly great. Unquestionably, it remains the finest finale of Bruckner’s Fifth I have ever heard, live or recorded.

Now we are approaching Zander’s final year with the orchestra. This may be his last performance of Bruckner’s Fifth with a baton in his hand, at least with this orchestra, since the organization is closing down. It could certainly be an interesting performance to attend.

Rerurn to Romy the Cat's Site