Rerurn to Romy the Cat's Site


In the Forum: Horn-Loaded Speakers
In the Thread: Another time aligned 5-way horn project
Post Subject: OK, good luck.Posted by Romy the Cat on: 11/10/2015
fiogf49gjkf0d
 Murataltuev wrote:
Romy, read my first post here.I told from the beginning that I'm going to try all kind of respected drivers to decide for myself what I like most.This is not about system as a whole with crossovering and other things. It is about sound of exact driver for exact range in most suitable horn for this range.For midBass and upperBass I've finally decided to use GOTO SG-146 - 4" throat in 46Hz and 200Hz LeCleach.For the 500+hz range I'm going to compare WE555, GOTO-555, Vitavox S2 and JBLs. For next range S2 and JBLs. Then RAAL and may be GOTO-SG17.I'm lucky to have all of them in my room and why not to evaluate ?You insist that I'm doing wrong, but honestly, I don't understand what are you talking about. And my impression, that you need to answer yourself why you worry about such a simple thing as comparison of different drivers.
 
Well, perhaps I have more respect to the subject then to the people who do not understand the subject? You are taking about bolting different brands and models of driver to a random pile of acoustic irrelevancy and listening unsystematic results by the ears which have no idea what to listen, by the brain that has very little experience how to interpret the heard and by a mind that has no understanding about metrological discipline.  Why do you think I invest very little into my expectations from your experiments?
 Murataltuev wrote:
You don't know anything about my listening intelligence and better not to mention anything about it.

Actually I do. I read plenty of your posts and well observed the way how you interpret what you hear. I also paid attention to the way how you repeat and editorialize the words of others and I know very much who those others are. While you do it you feel that you extend the subject and compliment the subject with your own take but in reality you in fact do misunderstand the subject. I have seen it a few times and it was very indicative to me.
 Murataltuev wrote:
Imagine that I have my own unintelligent expectations and want to fulfill them anyway. I'm not suggesting you anything from my unintelligent taste and not gong to further post my impressions, so don't worry.

Sure, no one suggest that you should not fulfill your own expectations. Whatever make you happy! It is my verdict that your expectations has nothing to do with what I feel might be used as vicarious learning and I have very little expectations from your finding. There are other people at this forum and you might post whatever you want but I think you need to know my general outlook about your practice. Real sonic result does not come from running over stupidly “testing” an army of drives but perfecting of one driver. You do not know what it means at this point  but it is OK.
 Murataltuev wrote:
Regarding driver loading I'm not sure that you know everything about it. You can't explain how I get 150hz in 200hz LeCleach and your imaginations about driver with 2 springs are very irrelevant to what it is in reality. You don't understand superiority of compression driver for the low frequencies. You think that LeCleach's curl is useless for low frequencies. You don't trust HornResp. You just have your own explanation of things like anybody else. Nothing special - believe me. Everyone is the same. Everyone want to think that he is special and has some unique knowledge, but it is never true. So, I suggest you to be open for others experience. This is more respectable, I believe.

God, how the hell I deserve all of it? I do not want to explain to you each point – you will not understand. I will tell you only one thing. I am not against the HornResp but I am against the HornResp or RTA in the hand of the people like you. You people have no idea how to interpreted graphs and how they related to actual listening experience and in my view your “measurements” are irrelevant.
 Murataltuev wrote:
I'm posting only in my SoundEx thread, because I want to share my experience to get opinions and suggestions from other experienced people. I'm not trying to teach, I'm trying to learn. You are tying to be The Great Master laughing on morons...ok...no problem  No one heard your system...who knows...may be the great king is naked 
Nope, laughing about Morons one do not need to insist to be a Great Master or to pretend to be experienced with great audio. The sad thing in this whole story is that I am not laughing about what you do. In fact I took it is very seriously, listened you attentively and told you what I think you should do - take a fucking time and build in your mind a sense of own actions. Instead of trying to think and to understand what and why I recommend it you went for exact opposite – a barbaric and brainless actions.  That is why I am not interested: I was there, I know what it leads to. You might (or not might) “get” it in 10-15 years, until then enjoy your life but all attention that you will get from me would be a presumption of foolishness.
 

Rerurn to Romy the Cat's Site