Rerurn to Romy the Cat's Site
In the Forum: Playback Listening
In the Thread: Basic guide to advanced audio
Post Subject: Good illustration but bad reasoning in my view.Posted by Romy the Cat on: 7/29/2011
fiogf49gjkf0d
I very much like he graphic illustration of the phenomena that Haralanov is trying to advocate but I very much disagree with Haralanov conclusions.
The integration of HF MIGHT and MIGHT NOT have the effect that Haralanov described. The effect he describe and depicted might wary from many different properties of sound reproduction, including from the performance of HF. Still, if the change from left image presentation to right image presentation is possible with no modification of HF then would we admin that HF has nothing to do with it?
Where I think Haralanov is right is that in context of a given playback and the given HF problem the HF might change the presentation from left to right image but it is only because the HF are basically bad and by user tune them to the state where they affect sound less negative. The reality is that very good, or even great HF shell not change presentation from left to right, they shall make sound brighter but still perfectly listenable and with no major impact to presentation scale.
So, what I feel is that Haralanov present the specific and very explicit presumably positive result that he got from his specific tweeter as some kind of universal solution about tweeters presentation. I do not think that it is accurate and I am absolutely insist that output of good tweeters shall not affect geometry of presentation in that way how Haralanov depicted.
The CatRerurn to Romy the Cat's Site