Rerurn to Romy the Cat's Site


In the Forum: Musical Discussions
In the Thread: Bruckner, me and the Seventh
Post Subject: Bruckner fantasyPosted by unicon on: 12/16/2010
fiogf49gjkf0d
 zako wrote:
After listening to Bruckner many many times,,  And professionally recording his compositions,, I am compelled to make this auwfull statement,,, I feel that he is a second rate composer,,,He,s done a large body of work,,But his overall statement,,,TO ME is repitisially boering,,,  I sat there looking at his score " the V11" (while recording) and thought he missed a good oppertunity,here, to rephrese and pull this symphony around and make it great,,,But he slips into his bad habbit of repitionally sliding back into the Bruckterian muck,,, I,m not trying to offend Bruckner followers here,,But just expressing my feelings,,,I wiil go down stairs and again audition The Sym,V11 today,,as a pennence. 



Zako you are absolutely right ... I even consider him worse than second hand composer.
Playing Bruckner I never can figure out which symphony I am hearing 1,2 ..7 (beside the symphony no 3, 8 lll)
He just went on making it a routine. you need to be in your good routine daily life while listening to it and you need some bottles of wine
and think about nothing.
anyhow I do not consider anyone like Brcukner as second hand listener.
but I definitely consider it too painful repeating some of his works , it is like being in audio hell introduced by Bruckner himself.

unicon

Rerurn to Romy the Cat's Site