Rerurn to Romy the Cat's Site

Musical Discussions
Topic: My Complicated Relationship with the Boston Symphony Orchestra

Page 1 of 1 (3 items)


Posted by steverino on 11-06-2026
Since Romy is in the environs I was curious about what is going on at the BSO. This is the summary I got:

The Boston Symphony Orchestra (BSO) has reported a $27 million surplus for fiscal 2025, alongside an endowment valued at approximately $603 million. Despite the positive financial indicators, the BSO has experienced a 40% decline in attendance over the past 20 years. This trend raises concerns about the orchestra's long-term viability and audience engagement.

I was frankly surprised at the massive attendance decline in just the last 20 years.  I get it that the BSO is currently viable financially but it is hard to see how they can continue this way if the endowment doesn't generate enough income to cover operating expenses.  A recession  I assume would cause severe problems. Is there a connection between these financial issues and the Andris Nelsons termination?

Posted by Romy the Cat on 11-19-2026
I truly do not know. I am sure there are many people who closely follow what happens with the Boston Symphony Orchestra, and they have their own judgments about it. I do not. For the last five or six years, I have stopped paying much attention to the BSO. There are several reasons for this, and one of the primary ones is Andris Nelsons.

I do not find him a particularly interesting conductor. I have encountered a few quite wonderful performances under his direction, primarily with the Tanglewood Music Center Orchestra. His performances with the BSO, however, I find unconvincing and, quite often, uncomfortable. I certainly do not question his technical abilities as a conductor, and it is none of my business to evaluate him as a musician. But it is very much my business to say that what he does with music is simply not what interests me. What he does as the music director of the Boston Symphony Orchestra is another matter. Unfortunately, in my view, it is a disaster.

You see, Boston did not simply have great conductors. We had something considerably more important: the presence of major cultural and musical personalities who shaped the musical identity of the city. There was a certain magnitude of judgment, a certain intellectual and artistic authority, that made the Boston Symphony Orchestra special. We had Serge Koussevitzky, who, for a variety of reasons—and not the least of them being his wife's money—was a spectacular thinker when it came to the musical life of Boston. Under his leadership, the BSO became a truly world-class orchestra. His contribution extended far beyond the quality of individual performances. He shaped the musical culture of the city.

Then we had a few rather nice, short-lived figures. And then came Seiji Ozawa. During his first years, he was an absolutely spectacular, positive, and beneficial force for the orchestra. What followed, unfortunately, was approximately twenty-nine years of something resembling darkness. Then came James Levine. His first two or three years were absolutely amazing. There was an extraordinary sense of possibility. But somehow, within a relatively short time, much of that promise ended in almost nothing.

And then we got Nelsons. Nelsons is a very interesting fruit. He is a good conductor, and he is an interesting person. But he simply does not possess the charisma necessary to move public opinion in the American cultural market in one direction or another. And this is precisely what some of Boston's previous music directors were able to accomplish.

Boston does not need merely another good conductor. Boston needs a musical director of the city. Someone capable of coordinating its musical efforts, shaping its cultural direction, and bringing the public toward a better, richer, more diverse understanding of classical music. Someone who can expand what people are willing to hear, appreciate, and understand. We actually have such a person in Boston. His name is Benjamin Zander.

Zander is the music director of our local Boston Philharmonic, a relatively small, largely amateur orchestra. And he is a spectacular figure when it comes to precisely this kind of cultural leadership. In my view, he would make a remarkably good music director of the Boston Symphony Orchestra. There is, of course, a problem. As a conductor, Zander is perhaps a little below the technical level one normally expects from the leaders of major professional orchestras. But as a musical personality, as someone capable of bringing people into the world of music and changing their understanding of it, he possesses something that Boston desperately needs.

So here is what we have in Boston today, at least in my view. We have Zander, who is approaching the end of his career, perhaps even his final season. And I must admit that his four concerts a year are significantly more interesting to me than many dozens of performances by the Boston Symphony Orchestra. And then we have the BSO. You can attend a hundred performances, and perhaps one of them will accidentally turn out to be good. The rest, to me, are simply not particularly interesting.

I personally stopped attending BSO concerts quite intentionally after a performance of Brahms under Nelsons. I attended a concert featuring two Brahms symphonies. I left after the second movement of the First Symphony. It was that bad. It was beyond the level of an amateur orchestra. It was a nightmare. I literally could not bring myself to listen to the BSO again. Occasionally, I still hear their live broadcasts on the radio, and I must admit that sometimes I actually like what I hear. So I am certainly not claiming that everything they do is bad. But my willingness to go to Symphony Hall and subject myself to another disappointment has largely disappeared.

There is also another dimension to my relationship with the orchestra, and I should acknowledge it. I am currently going through an exceptionally nasty divorce. And, unfortunately, it is not simply a divorce from my wife. In many respects, it feels like a divorce from her entire family. One of Amy's sisters plays in the Boston Symphony Orchestra, and that makes the orchestra personally uncomfortable for me. I would very much prefer that my relationship with music remain uncontaminated by my personal feelings. Music is too important to me to become an extension of a family conflict. But I recognize that these circumstances may influence my perception, and I would rather acknowledge that possibility than pretend it does not exist.

So I have a rather strange relationship with the BSO. Many years ago, perhaps twenty or thirty years ago, Clark Johnson told me about a friend of his who disliked the Boston Symphony Orchestra so intensely that he actually moved to Maine, simply to be farther away from it. At the time, I thought this was rather extreme. Actually, I still think it is extreme. But I understand the man.

Imagine living in a wonderful city, a city with a world-famous orchestra, an orchestra celebrated internationally as one of the great musical institutions, and feeling that what it produces is shit. If classical music is genuinely important to you, if it occupies a central place in your intellectual and emotional life, then I can understand the desire to remove yourself from that environment. Even moving away from the city can become a legitimate form of protest. It is a little obsessive, of course. A little bit. But to me, it is a perfectly understandable course of action.

I do not live in Boston anymore. I live approximately forty-five minutes away. And yet, whenever I see an interesting performance announced by the BSO, I find myself asking a rather peculiar question: Do I actually want to go there? Do I want to make the trip, spend the evening in Symphony Hall, and expose myself to another potentially enormous disappointment? Because quite a few of those trips have ended exactly that way.

Having said all this, I am going to Boston this Sunday to hear Bruckner's Fifth Symphony performed by the Boston Philharmonic. That orchestra also carries certain personal associations for me. My former wife played with the Boston Philharmonic, and inevitably there are memories attached to it. But those are personal problems I can recognize, and I believe I can handle them without allowing them to affect my experience of the music.

Posted by Paul S on 11-19-2026
Romy, I could not agree more. And despite I have heard good performances from our local SO on the radio, I have very rarely heard their best when I was in attendance; in fact, I have left early more often than not when I attended alone. I wish you good luck with live Bruckner 5, as most conductors seem to realize that most orchestras have to play a version they can actually play, end to end. I happened to hear our local SO on the radio just recently, via an archived Bruckner 5, and it was "not bad", by which I mean the guest conductor streamlined it, to help the orchestra get through it, and - indeed - the orchestra did not screw up or run out of gas. For my own edification and enjoyment, I want to hear SO performances that I want to hear again. Based on 40 years of experience, I pre-suppose I will probably not get this locally, despite they do it every so often. Ironically, I am more likely to hear the best of the local SO on the radio, depending on who is choosing the program. And, yes, I have tried "cherry picking" performances.

Paul S

Page 1 of 1 (3 items)