Rerurn to Romy the Cat's Site

Analog Playback
Topic: Symptom of worn out bearing?

Page 1 of 1 (8 items)


Posted by wonderworld on 02-03-2014
fiogf49gjkf0d
I was offered to buy Micro seiki RX5000. The seller sent me a short video. If you see it carefully you will notice that the platter moving slightly up and down. Is that that normal or this could be sign that the bearing is not in good condition? http://youtu.be/StrQXmiPfcI

Posted by Romy the Cat on 02-04-2014
fiogf49gjkf0d
Yes, it does look like “wrong” but I do not think that it is an indication of a problem. The bearing would not give you the wobbling that you would be able to see with your eyes. It is also very unlikely that the platter has different high and not balanced. I do think that it is some kind optical illusion or camera was moving. I do not know. However, I do not think that it shall be a problem.

Posted by be on 02-05-2014
fiogf49gjkf0d
I you play the video full screen and place the cursor at the top or the bottom edge of the platter, it seems clear that the the platter wobbles since they go up and down synchronously and the upper edge of the turntable chassis is not moving at all.

It could cause some wow since the radius of the platter, as sensed of the string, will vary.
Furthermore the tracking angle would change more than some people would like?
Also it might cause terminal sea sickness just looking at it.

Posted by wonderworld on 02-05-2014
fiogf49gjkf0d
Is there any way to choose the "right wife" only by video and photos whithout trying her? Wink You are well experienced Romy, which are the symptoms of the "wrong", wobbling or worn out bearing when we buy Micro Seiki RX or SX? Anyway I would like to get merried in a right MS8000, how to recognize the "right" TT shaft? Here is an video example of another used RX5000 for sale with even worse moving up and down platter: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0z5slGdeivs

Posted by wonderworld on 02-05-2014
fiogf49gjkf0d
It seems that all of much used Micro RX or SX TT's have the same problem, is that right? It will be nice if more of other owners of RX or SX TT's share their observations and experience regarding this problem...  attached is one more video of other RX5000 for sale and it looks even worse, the need of medicine for sea sickness is infallible: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0z5slGdeivs

Posted by Romy the Cat on 02-05-2014
fiogf49gjkf0d
 wonderworld wrote:
It seems that all of much used Micro RX or SX TT's have the same problem, is that right? It will be nice if more of other owners of RX or SX TT's share their observations and experience regarding this problem... attached is one more video of other RX5000 for sale and it looks even worse, the need of medicine for sea sickness is infallible

Wonderworld, you have opened a whole new word to me. I never saw a TT that does such a thing. The bearing can’t wobble so much. The bearing is a cylinder of 4-5 inch, it certainly cannot wobble. If it is air suspension then wobble is 12” sheet of glass – it can’t wobble like this. The only think that I would propose is that the platter might not be Micro made platter but was made at some kind of bogus sweatshop where they made variable platter high, making platter imbalanced. I very much doubt that somebody would make the platters so badly. I do stay with proposal that it is optical illusion some kind.

To comfort yourself your need to take one of the test records that has a continuing pitch, let say 440Ha. Some of them do have it. Play it on that wobbling TT and hear if the pitch will fluctuate. Alternately you can put 4 identical small mirrors on the platter. Reflect a fixed laser pointer to a wall from one of the mirror. Mark the reflection spot on the opposite wall. Then rotate the platter: the other 3 mirrors shall mark the very same spot on the wall.

Posted by Paul S on 02-05-2014
fiogf49gjkf0d
The bearing might be fine and one would see up-and-down at the platter rim if the (sub-)platter was not a constant, perfect 90 degrees relative to the bearing shaft, through the 360 degrees of rotation. Many ways misalignment might happen, only a few ways to make it right again. Not a DIY repair, I suspect.


Paul S

Posted by wonderworld on 11-13-2014
fiogf49gjkf0d
A few months ago I have bought almost new RX5000 from US and I am happy with it... somebody told me an idea to mark the platter and to count how many turns it will do from 33 r.p.m. until completely stops and I have counted about 30 to 32 full turns until completely stops. I think this is one of the ways to check how good is the bearing.

Now I am a guest of a seller who sell his SX 8000 I (note that is the first 8000 version) and I did the same procedure: I have pasted a small white piece of paper on its platter and the full turns was only 12 from 33 r.p.m. until the 8000I platter completely stopped to turn. 

Romy and other guys who have 8000I model,  I would like to ask you to do the same experiment and to count and tell me how many turns will do your 8000I TT's platters from 33 r.p.m. until they completely stop?

Thank you in advance!    

Page 1 of 1 (8 items)